Why would I change to Forwo
Original Post
The instructions for the new, improved combo platter AF says:
"When you decide the “Change to Forward Mode” task is ready to be actioned"...
I haven't been able to find any explanation of WHY this would stand out. I'm not clear why I would want to switch to another mode. In other words, what does Forward Mode buy me that Reverse Mode does not?
Any advice? Thanks!
"When you decide the “Change to Forward Mode” task is ready to be actioned"...
I haven't been able to find any explanation of WHY this would stand out. I'm not clear why I would want to switch to another mode. In other words, what does Forward Mode buy me that Reverse Mode does not?
Any advice? Thanks!
Reply by Walter
Hi, ds
I asked the same question in another thread. This is Mark's answer:
"The main motivation would be that you felt that the beginning of the list needed more methodical attention.
You'd add the task to the list on your first day of using this method, and re-enter it whenever you actioned it like any other recurring task."
I admit that I haven't switched yet to FM, but that's mainly because I only have two active pages.
I assume that if these would be 10, I'd be switching frequently.
I wonder why Backwards Mode is done in a sequential way, while Forward mode is done like AF1, looping through the same page.
I asked the same question in another thread. This is Mark's answer:
"The main motivation would be that you felt that the beginning of the list needed more methodical attention.
You'd add the task to the list on your first day of using this method, and re-enter it whenever you actioned it like any other recurring task."
I admit that I haven't switched yet to FM, but that's mainly because I only have two active pages.
I assume that if these would be 10, I'd be switching frequently.
I wonder why Backwards Mode is done in a sequential way, while Forward mode is done like AF1, looping through the same page.
Reply by Mark Forster
ds:
To quote the instructions:
"Forward Mode is primarily intended for taking action on less urgent tasks which have not been dealt with by Reverse Mode, though it is not restricted exclusively to non-urgent tasks."
It will become clearer to you after you have been working the system for a bit.
To quote the instructions:
"Forward Mode is primarily intended for taking action on less urgent tasks which have not been dealt with by Reverse Mode, though it is not restricted exclusively to non-urgent tasks."
It will become clearer to you after you have been working the system for a bit.
Reply by Mark Forster
Walter:
<< I wonder why Backwards Mode is done in a sequential way, while Forward mode is done like AF1, looping through the same page. >>
Because an open list approach is more suited to urgent tasks, and a closed list approach to important but non-urgent tasks.
<< I wonder why Backwards Mode is done in a sequential way, while Forward mode is done like AF1, looping through the same page. >>
Because an open list approach is more suited to urgent tasks, and a closed list approach to important but non-urgent tasks.
Reply by Man of Kent
How about because you want a change from working the end of the list..... The key for me is that the system keeps you working when otherwise I'd just drift.
Reply by Walter
Thanks, Mark.
Reply by ds
Thanks for the quick answers, everybody!
Reply by Seraphim
Simple curiosity about the mechanics of the Revised AF is what drew me to Forward Mode. On my first day with RAF, I had been working in Reverse Mode most of the day, but had just been wondering what effect Forward Mode would have. That curiosity caused the task to "feel ready to be done". So I switched.
That curiosity about the mechanics of the system has continued to draw me to Forward Mode several times.
I am really liking the results -- I am feeling "on top" of my list again. Haven't really felt that way since the introduction of AF2 and my foray into my own mixed-mode version. I think Mark has really hit a sweet spot with the mechanics of this new system.
That curiosity about the mechanics of the system has continued to draw me to Forward Mode several times.
I am really liking the results -- I am feeling "on top" of my list again. Haven't really felt that way since the introduction of AF2 and my foray into my own mixed-mode version. I think Mark has really hit a sweet spot with the mechanics of this new system.
Reply by Mark Forster
Seraphim:
That's good to hear, especially as I know you were one of the first people to try out a combo.
One thing that's struck me very forcibly about the comments on the Revised Autofocus System is that no one has yet proposed any tweaks. That must be a good thing!
That's good to hear, especially as I know you were one of the first people to try out a combo.
One thing that's struck me very forcibly about the comments on the Revised Autofocus System is that no one has yet proposed any tweaks. That must be a good thing!
Reply by Will
Give us a couple more days, Mark!
Reply by Mike
Mark,
>>> One thing that's struck me very forcibly about the comments on the Revised Autofocus System is that no one has yet proposed any tweaks. That must be a good thing! <<<
You've just not heard yet ;-) Actually, I've done a good bit of tweaking but I don't think it serves anyone well to post a lot of tweaks to something so new.
But since you asked:
- I test all newly added items: "Will I REALLY do this in the next week?" (If no, I dismiss it right then. (Adding it first allows me to keep the grass catcher attribute of AF. Dismissing it immediately keeps AF clean of clutter.)
- I replaced the AF1 dismissal rule into the Forward Mode. (I foresaw the infinite loop problem and this prevents it.)
- I allow immediate "rescue" of dismissed tasks and add them to the END of the list with a ! (I wish I could remember who gave me that idea.) This solves my problem of being forced to dismiss items I don't want to ... yet it should not allow a cop out. We'll see.
- I keep a 20 minute timer going in both modes and check where I am when it goes off. (I was originally going to switch based on the timer but experience showed me that I was often in the middle of something and so could not switch anyway).
- My first scan of the day is to pull off high priority items and put them on my MUST DO TODAY list ... that list gets worked first and I only start AF when I can no longer progress there. When I hit a "switch" condition, I first go back to that MUST DO list before I go to the other AF Mode. So my sequence is:
.- AF Scan
.- Must Do List
.- AF Reverse Mode
.- Must Do List
.- AF Forward Mode
.- etc.
Formalizing how I embed AF into the other parts of my systems has helped considerably.
I've made some "mechanical" changes which don't affect the rules of AF. I'm still working from a pocket notebook but I think I'll make the backup recording in Excel to monitor statistics a permanent thing. (If I ever get the spreadsheet working the way I want. I did try to collect the statistics manually but after coming up with different task counts every time I counted, I gave up on that idea ;-)
But all of these tweaks are to accommodate how I work ... and I do work differently than many others so I can really see RAF needing many fewer tweaks over all.
>>> One thing that's struck me very forcibly about the comments on the Revised Autofocus System is that no one has yet proposed any tweaks. That must be a good thing! <<<
You've just not heard yet ;-) Actually, I've done a good bit of tweaking but I don't think it serves anyone well to post a lot of tweaks to something so new.
But since you asked:
- I test all newly added items: "Will I REALLY do this in the next week?" (If no, I dismiss it right then. (Adding it first allows me to keep the grass catcher attribute of AF. Dismissing it immediately keeps AF clean of clutter.)
- I replaced the AF1 dismissal rule into the Forward Mode. (I foresaw the infinite loop problem and this prevents it.)
- I allow immediate "rescue" of dismissed tasks and add them to the END of the list with a ! (I wish I could remember who gave me that idea.) This solves my problem of being forced to dismiss items I don't want to ... yet it should not allow a cop out. We'll see.
- I keep a 20 minute timer going in both modes and check where I am when it goes off. (I was originally going to switch based on the timer but experience showed me that I was often in the middle of something and so could not switch anyway).
- My first scan of the day is to pull off high priority items and put them on my MUST DO TODAY list ... that list gets worked first and I only start AF when I can no longer progress there. When I hit a "switch" condition, I first go back to that MUST DO list before I go to the other AF Mode. So my sequence is:
.- AF Scan
.- Must Do List
.- AF Reverse Mode
.- Must Do List
.- AF Forward Mode
.- etc.
Formalizing how I embed AF into the other parts of my systems has helped considerably.
I've made some "mechanical" changes which don't affect the rules of AF. I'm still working from a pocket notebook but I think I'll make the backup recording in Excel to monitor statistics a permanent thing. (If I ever get the spreadsheet working the way I want. I did try to collect the statistics manually but after coming up with different task counts every time I counted, I gave up on that idea ;-)
But all of these tweaks are to accommodate how I work ... and I do work differently than many others so I can really see RAF needing many fewer tweaks over all.
Reply by Seraphim
Hi Mike,
All those tweaks make it seem really complicated to me. I'd never be able to remember, let alone follow, all those rules.
(But if it works for you, great!)
On the "endless loop" problem -- I have actually come to like this effect. It gives you repeated exposure to those early tasks in your book. That repeated exposure helps overcome resistance.
If I find that even after that repeated exposure, they are still not getting done, then I can just decide to delete them, or put them on review.
But if you make it a rule to just always put them on review before switching back to Reverse Mode, you lose this repeated exposure.
All those tweaks make it seem really complicated to me. I'd never be able to remember, let alone follow, all those rules.
(But if it works for you, great!)
On the "endless loop" problem -- I have actually come to like this effect. It gives you repeated exposure to those early tasks in your book. That repeated exposure helps overcome resistance.
If I find that even after that repeated exposure, they are still not getting done, then I can just decide to delete them, or put them on review.
But if you make it a rule to just always put them on review before switching back to Reverse Mode, you lose this repeated exposure.
Reply by Mark Forster
Mike:
Wow!
I seem to achieve all those things without needing to use any tweaks at all. I've taken action on every single one of the first 323 tasks which I put on the new list that I started ten days ago.
Have you actually tried it without tweaks?
Wow!
I seem to achieve all those things without needing to use any tweaks at all. I've taken action on every single one of the first 323 tasks which I put on the new list that I started ten days ago.
Have you actually tried it without tweaks?
Reply by Martin H
Mark:
Do you pre filter your tasks? I'm amazed that you've actually done something on every one of your tasks! I find myself adding a number of tasks which, on review, would essentially be a diversion from the goals I really want to achieve. Really useful to have written them down in AF but I'm not sure that I would necessarily expect to be do something on all of them.
Martin
Do you pre filter your tasks? I'm amazed that you've actually done something on every one of your tasks! I find myself adding a number of tasks which, on review, would essentially be a diversion from the goals I really want to achieve. Really useful to have written them down in AF but I'm not sure that I would necessarily expect to be do something on all of them.
Martin
Reply by Mike
Mark,
Here's the thing ... with AF1 things were going much better than my "old" way. My list was getting longer and I was starting to get just a bit frustrated with myself but it was all good. (I think I was up to something like 30 pages of 15 items each ... I don't recall how many tasks were open. (I'll report better soon, I hope.)
Then AF2 came along and things speeded up greatly. Kudos for that. But my frustration level went much higher because of that "moving line of doom". My frustration increased to the point that I had to figure out how to deal with it and I decided a complete overhaul was required.
Just as I was about to implement MY system, you announced RAF. RAF did not have the changes I figured I needed for ME to work MY way and get things done to a level satisfaction. But when I compared my system (with AF2 as an integral part of it vs. with RAF as an integral part of it) it made sense to use RAF with my changes rather than stick with AF2. (If that makes any sense to you.)
So the system I am implementing (testing right now) is as I partially described ... RAF with the changes I found I needed from being frustrated with AF2. (Basically keep the list clean and small and have priorities in my face.)
Have I tried RAF with no changes? No. The thing is that each time I try the system without the changes I feel I need, I just thrash around and get frustrated.
I will never be able to use a system that does not have a feature to schedule and prioritize. My mind does not work in such a way as to allow me to be successful without priorities and schedules. Think of it this way ... how frustrated would YOU be if you tried to use a system that required priorities and scheduling things to do during the day rather than using your intuitive approach? That would probably work just as poorly for you as "leaving it to my intuition" does for me.
If RAF would not leave me with crucial things undone at the end of the day, I'd jump right in. But without having a list of a half-dozen or so things that MUST be done today staring me in my face ... I'm lost. I just can't afford to let those things get mixed in with "Wash the Car" and "Mop the Floors" and "Re-read Dickens". LOL ;-) Remember ... ADD! ;-) Your methods work well to help those with ADD ... except where something is crucial with respect to time ... then they play into our weakness ... distraction. Given enough time, I'd see the important things ... but perhaps too late.
Now, all of that said, one possibility is that I'll hit a patch where there is nothing crucial going on and so, by default, I'll be working RAF with check-ins to a NULL High Priority list which will be closer to RAF. At which point I may have a revelation. Or not. Who knows?
I can tell you one thing for sure ... the simple modification of asking if I am committed to doing a new task this week, right after adding it, has made the most difference. In my transition, I asked that question of every item on my list and pages just vanished. I went crazy with dismissal. With the question now encoded in my procedure, maybe 10-20% of new tasks are instantly dismissed. (Squirrel! ;-)
Here's the thing ... with AF1 things were going much better than my "old" way. My list was getting longer and I was starting to get just a bit frustrated with myself but it was all good. (I think I was up to something like 30 pages of 15 items each ... I don't recall how many tasks were open. (I'll report better soon, I hope.)
Then AF2 came along and things speeded up greatly. Kudos for that. But my frustration level went much higher because of that "moving line of doom". My frustration increased to the point that I had to figure out how to deal with it and I decided a complete overhaul was required.
Just as I was about to implement MY system, you announced RAF. RAF did not have the changes I figured I needed for ME to work MY way and get things done to a level satisfaction. But when I compared my system (with AF2 as an integral part of it vs. with RAF as an integral part of it) it made sense to use RAF with my changes rather than stick with AF2. (If that makes any sense to you.)
So the system I am implementing (testing right now) is as I partially described ... RAF with the changes I found I needed from being frustrated with AF2. (Basically keep the list clean and small and have priorities in my face.)
Have I tried RAF with no changes? No. The thing is that each time I try the system without the changes I feel I need, I just thrash around and get frustrated.
I will never be able to use a system that does not have a feature to schedule and prioritize. My mind does not work in such a way as to allow me to be successful without priorities and schedules. Think of it this way ... how frustrated would YOU be if you tried to use a system that required priorities and scheduling things to do during the day rather than using your intuitive approach? That would probably work just as poorly for you as "leaving it to my intuition" does for me.
If RAF would not leave me with crucial things undone at the end of the day, I'd jump right in. But without having a list of a half-dozen or so things that MUST be done today staring me in my face ... I'm lost. I just can't afford to let those things get mixed in with "Wash the Car" and "Mop the Floors" and "Re-read Dickens". LOL ;-) Remember ... ADD! ;-) Your methods work well to help those with ADD ... except where something is crucial with respect to time ... then they play into our weakness ... distraction. Given enough time, I'd see the important things ... but perhaps too late.
Now, all of that said, one possibility is that I'll hit a patch where there is nothing crucial going on and so, by default, I'll be working RAF with check-ins to a NULL High Priority list which will be closer to RAF. At which point I may have a revelation. Or not. Who knows?
I can tell you one thing for sure ... the simple modification of asking if I am committed to doing a new task this week, right after adding it, has made the most difference. In my transition, I asked that question of every item on my list and pages just vanished. I went crazy with dismissal. With the question now encoded in my procedure, maybe 10-20% of new tasks are instantly dismissed. (Squirrel! ;-)
Reply by Mark Forster
MartinH:
No, I don't pre-filter my tasks at all. On the other hand I'm not such a complete idiot as to put down every possible thing that I might do in the next twenty years - but then I don't expect either you or Mike are either.
I just put my first task on review this morning. It was to start a photo gallery on Flickr. Have I got time to do that at the moment? - No. Would I still like to do it sometime? - Yes.
The system coped perfectly well with that.
No, I don't pre-filter my tasks at all. On the other hand I'm not such a complete idiot as to put down every possible thing that I might do in the next twenty years - but then I don't expect either you or Mike are either.
I just put my first task on review this morning. It was to start a photo gallery on Flickr. Have I got time to do that at the moment? - No. Would I still like to do it sometime? - Yes.
The system coped perfectly well with that.
Reply by Mark Forster
Mike:
As I've frequently said before, I don't want to stop anyone doing anything that works for them.
But of course I've used scheduling and prioritising systems. I had 34 years of working life before I started inventing my own systems, and used that type of system extensively.
The thing is that I find that Revised AF makes me more likely to get the deadline stuff done on time without panic than any of the old systems. It is proving itself to be superior with both urgent and important but non-urgent stuff too.
And I get the fun stuff done as well!
As I've frequently said before, I don't want to stop anyone doing anything that works for them.
But of course I've used scheduling and prioritising systems. I had 34 years of working life before I started inventing my own systems, and used that type of system extensively.
The thing is that I find that Revised AF makes me more likely to get the deadline stuff done on time without panic than any of the old systems. It is proving itself to be superior with both urgent and important but non-urgent stuff too.
And I get the fun stuff done as well!
Reply by Mike
Mark,
>>> No, I don't pre-filter my tasks at all. On the other hand I'm not such a complete idiot as to put down every possible thing that I might do in the next twenty years - but then I don't expect either you or Mike are either. <<<
Are you dead sure about that one? ROTF ;-) It is not so much that I'd put something like that on my list ... I'd not. It might find its way into my long range goal planning ... but would not go on my To Do list. But what DOES get on there, and needs to be filtered (in my case) is the random "That might be something interesting to do someday" kind of thing. It is that "someday" that gets lost unless I "test it". It is probably just a processing glitch I've always had. My filters, in this case, don't work so well as yours do ... i.e. they don't work automatically in a reliable way. Another way to look at it is that everything fascinates me and I can imagine that I'd like to do it ... of course, I can't and won't, but while you automatically know and filter, I don't unless I think to ask myself ... or I get a clogged up To Do list and wonder why the "real" stuff is getting lost in the shuffle.
RE: your flicker example ... as I process things I would not know to take the item off of my list if I did not have a rule to ask the question. IOW, MY system coped perfectly, but MY system has a rule to ask that question ... you do so automatically (as I understand it).
RE: 34 years ... O.K. Gotcha. Then for some reason you are able to work in both kinds of system. Well, my wife has always told me I'm just a binary kind of guy ;-)
>>> No, I don't pre-filter my tasks at all. On the other hand I'm not such a complete idiot as to put down every possible thing that I might do in the next twenty years - but then I don't expect either you or Mike are either. <<<
Are you dead sure about that one? ROTF ;-) It is not so much that I'd put something like that on my list ... I'd not. It might find its way into my long range goal planning ... but would not go on my To Do list. But what DOES get on there, and needs to be filtered (in my case) is the random "That might be something interesting to do someday" kind of thing. It is that "someday" that gets lost unless I "test it". It is probably just a processing glitch I've always had. My filters, in this case, don't work so well as yours do ... i.e. they don't work automatically in a reliable way. Another way to look at it is that everything fascinates me and I can imagine that I'd like to do it ... of course, I can't and won't, but while you automatically know and filter, I don't unless I think to ask myself ... or I get a clogged up To Do list and wonder why the "real" stuff is getting lost in the shuffle.
RE: your flicker example ... as I process things I would not know to take the item off of my list if I did not have a rule to ask the question. IOW, MY system coped perfectly, but MY system has a rule to ask that question ... you do so automatically (as I understand it).
RE: 34 years ... O.K. Gotcha. Then for some reason you are able to work in both kinds of system. Well, my wife has always told me I'm just a binary kind of guy ;-)
Reply by Mark Forster
Mike:
<< RE: your flicker example ... as I process things I would not know to take the item off of my list if I did not have a rule to ask the question. >>
I don't quite understand what you mean here. It's taken off the list by following the rules for reviewing tasks (previously called dimissing tasks). The questions come later.
<< RE: your flicker example ... as I process things I would not know to take the item off of my list if I did not have a rule to ask the question. >>
I don't quite understand what you mean here. It's taken off the list by following the rules for reviewing tasks (previously called dimissing tasks). The questions come later.
Reply by Jacqueline
Re. the original question of why you'd want to return to forward mode - I like this mode as a way to finish off old, active pages with only a few items remaining. I suppose you could still do this in reverse mode, but you'd have to go back to the end every time.
Reply by Mike
Mark,
Sorry, we seem to be talking at cross purposes. I thought you saw that you wanted to dismiss the item right away.
In any case, the rule to dismiss will only kick in after the item has been hit a number of times and ignored. That is too long for me to wait to allow things to clutter up the the list. If it is something that is a serious possibility, then fine, but if it is something that came from one of my squirrel moments, then it has to go or it will eventually sink my list.
Sorry, we seem to be talking at cross purposes. I thought you saw that you wanted to dismiss the item right away.
In any case, the rule to dismiss will only kick in after the item has been hit a number of times and ignored. That is too long for me to wait to allow things to clutter up the the list. If it is something that is a serious possibility, then fine, but if it is something that came from one of my squirrel moments, then it has to go or it will eventually sink my list.